Purchasing an additional property can be a smart financial move, but not all properties serve the same purpose. Are you looking for a personal retreat for weekend getaways, or do you want a steady income stream from rental tenants? The difference between a second home and an investment property impacts everything from financing and taxes to long-term financial strategy, making it essential to choose wisely.
In Evanston, where historic homes, lakefront retreats, and high-demand rental properties offer diverse opportunities, understanding these distinctions is key. Whether you're considering a vacation home near Lake Michigan or a rental property near Northwestern University, knowing the benefits and challenges of each option will help you make a confident and strategic decision.
What Is a Second Home?
A second home is a property purchased primarily for personal use rather than as a source of rental income. This might be a vacation home, a weekend retreat, or a seasonal residence. Many homeowners in Evanston buy second homes to enjoy proximity to Lake Michigan, golf courses, and vibrant downtown amenities while maintaining their primary residence elsewhere.
While you may choose to rent out a second home occasionally, most lenders and tax regulations place limits on how frequently you can do so. This means second homes are best suited for buyers who prioritize personal enjoyment over financial gain.
While you may choose to rent out a second home occasionally, most lenders and tax regulations place limits on how frequently you can do so. This means second homes are best suited for buyers who prioritize personal enjoyment over financial gain.
What Is an Investment Property?
An investment property is purchased primarily to generate income through long-term rentals, short-term vacation rentals, or resale profits. Unlike second homes, investment properties can be rented out year-round, making them a popular choice for those looking to build passive income or grow their real estate portfolio.
Rental properties are in high demand in Evanston, driven by Northwestern University students, faculty, and Chicago commuters. Many investors target multi-family buildings, condos, and single-family homes in desirable neighborhoods where rental demand remains strong.
Rental properties are in high demand in Evanston, driven by Northwestern University students, faculty, and Chicago commuters. Many investors target multi-family buildings, condos, and single-family homes in desirable neighborhoods where rental demand remains strong.
Key Differences Between Second Homes and Investment Properties
1. Financing and Mortgage Requirements
Lenders classify second homes and investment properties differently, which affects loan terms, interest rates, and down payment requirements.
Second home mortgages typically offer lower interest rates and require a 10-20% down payment, depending on your financial profile. However, lenders often have strict criteria for what qualifies as a second home. Many require the property to be at least 50 miles away from your primary residence and limit how often it can be rented out.
Investment property loans come with higher interest rates and larger down payments, typically ranging from 20-25%. Since rental properties pose more financial risk to lenders, they require higher credit scores and stronger financial reserves to qualify. Additionally, rental income can sometimes be factored into loan approval, helping offset mortgage costs.
Second home mortgages typically offer lower interest rates and require a 10-20% down payment, depending on your financial profile. However, lenders often have strict criteria for what qualifies as a second home. Many require the property to be at least 50 miles away from your primary residence and limit how often it can be rented out.
Investment property loans come with higher interest rates and larger down payments, typically ranging from 20-25%. Since rental properties pose more financial risk to lenders, they require higher credit scores and stronger financial reserves to qualify. Additionally, rental income can sometimes be factored into loan approval, helping offset mortgage costs.
2. Tax Benefits and Implications
Taxes play a significant role in deciding whether to buy a second home or an investment property. The IRS treats them differently, which affects deductions, rental income taxation, and capital gains.
For second homes, mortgage interest and property taxes are deductible, similar to a primary residence. However, rental restrictions apply—if you rent the home for more than 14 days per year, it may be classified as an investment property, making you subject to income taxes on rental earnings.
Investment properties offer more extensive tax deductions, including expenses such as mortgage interest, property taxes, maintenance costs, property management fees, and depreciation. However, all rental income must be reported, and capital gains taxes apply if you sell the property for a profit.
For second homes, mortgage interest and property taxes are deductible, similar to a primary residence. However, rental restrictions apply—if you rent the home for more than 14 days per year, it may be classified as an investment property, making you subject to income taxes on rental earnings.
Investment properties offer more extensive tax deductions, including expenses such as mortgage interest, property taxes, maintenance costs, property management fees, and depreciation. However, all rental income must be reported, and capital gains taxes apply if you sell the property for a profit.
3. Usage and Rental Restrictions
The biggest difference between a second home and an investment property is how you can use it.
A second home is primarily intended for personal use. Many second-homeowners in Evanston use their properties seasonally or on weekends, enjoying the convenience of lakefront access, downtown shopping, and proximity to Chicago.
An investment property, on the other hand, is intended exclusively for rental income. There are no restrictions on renting, making it a great option for long-term tenants, vacation rentals, or multi-unit properties. However, landlords must comply with Evanston’s local rental laws, including zoning regulations, tenant rights, and licensing requirements for short-term rentals.
A second home is primarily intended for personal use. Many second-homeowners in Evanston use their properties seasonally or on weekends, enjoying the convenience of lakefront access, downtown shopping, and proximity to Chicago.
An investment property, on the other hand, is intended exclusively for rental income. There are no restrictions on renting, making it a great option for long-term tenants, vacation rentals, or multi-unit properties. However, landlords must comply with Evanston’s local rental laws, including zoning regulations, tenant rights, and licensing requirements for short-term rentals.
4. Return on Investment (ROI) Potential
When it comes to financial gain, investment properties typically provide higher ROI than second homes. Rental income helps offset mortgage costs and provides passive cash flow, while appreciation over time increases long-term value.
Second homes, however, rely on market appreciation to generate profit, as they aren’t designed to produce consistent income. If you’re looking for a personal retreat that may increase in value over time, a second home is a great choice. If income generation is the priority, an investment property is the better option.
Second homes, however, rely on market appreciation to generate profit, as they aren’t designed to produce consistent income. If you’re looking for a personal retreat that may increase in value over time, a second home is a great choice. If income generation is the priority, an investment property is the better option.
5. Long-Term Financial Strategy
Before purchasing, consider how the property fits into your long-term financial goals. If your priority is lifestyle enhancement, a second home offers a place to escape and unwind. Evanston’s charming lakefront areas and vibrant downtown scene make it a desirable location for those who want a second residence without committing to full-time city living.
If building wealth and diversifying assets is your goal, an investment property provides monthly cash flow and long-term appreciation, making it a solid addition to your financial portfolio. With Evanston’s high demand for rentals due to its college town atmosphere and easy access to Chicago, investment properties can be lucrative for the right buyer.
If building wealth and diversifying assets is your goal, an investment property provides monthly cash flow and long-term appreciation, making it a solid addition to your financial portfolio. With Evanston’s high demand for rentals due to its college town atmosphere and easy access to Chicago, investment properties can be lucrative for the right buyer.
Which Option Is Right for You?
Deciding between a second home and an investment property depends on your personal goals, financial situation, and lifestyle preferences. If you’re looking for a weekend retreat or seasonal escape, a second home offers the perfect getaway. If you’re focused on generating income and maximizing ROI, an investment property provides financial growth opportunities.
Understanding how each option affects financing, taxes, and long-term strategy is key to making a smart real estate decision. Working with a knowledgeable Evanston real estate expert can help you determine the best path based on your needs and market trends.
Understanding how each option affects financing, taxes, and long-term strategy is key to making a smart real estate decision. Working with a knowledgeable Evanston real estate expert can help you determine the best path based on your needs and market trends.
Local Expertise from Trusted Evanston Real Estate Advisors
Making a sound decision about purchasing a second home or an investment property is easier when you have local market experts guiding you. Mary Summerville and Jason Cox are seasoned Evanston real estate professionals known for their deep market insight and personalized approach. Their expertise spans everything from evaluating rental ROI potential to identifying hidden-gem second homes along Lake Michigan’s shoreline. Partnering with experienced local agents ensures you understand neighborhood trends, zoning nuances, and investment projections before you buy.
Explore Your Evanston Real Estate Options with Expert Guidance
Whether you're searching for a second home for personal enjoyment or an investment property to generate income, having a real estate expert on your side makes all the difference. Summerville Partners can help you navigate the Evanston real estate market, ensuring you make a smart investment that aligns with your financial goals.
Contact Summerville Partners today to explore second home and investment property opportunities in Evanston and find the right fit for your lifestyle and future plans.
Contact Summerville Partners today to explore second home and investment property opportunities in Evanston and find the right fit for your lifestyle and future plans.
Other Recommended Reads:
