A red-brick home with white sash windows and limestone entrance steps beyond a deep autumn lawn and curved brick walk.

Winnetka's First Holiday Season Without the Post Office: The Lawn, the Corner, and the Calendar Downtown

  • October 29, 2026

The Winnetka-Northfield-Glencoe Chamber of Commerce has posted its invitation to the annual tree lighting, and it still gives the location as Dwyer Park, "near the intersection of Elm and Birch, just behind the post office." The post office isn't there anymore. Crews demolished the building in the spring, and the parcel at 512 Chestnut St. is now a plain lawn while the village works out what comes next.

Across Elm, the other big downtown project is in a similar spot. It looks finished from the street, but its doors are still closed. That makes this an unusual holiday season. Neither of the two largest sites in downtown Winnetka is open to the public right now. The Community House, the Saturday market and the tree lighting are carrying the blocks around Elm and Chestnut, and they will until the buildings are ready. Knowing which spots are open, which are waiting, and what's still undecided makes the next six weeks downtown easier to plan.

First, where the mail went

You'll feel this change first if you have holiday packages to send. The U.S. Postal Service moved Winnetka's post office to 586 Lincoln Ave. in late 2025, before the old Chestnut Street building came down. That address is the one to use in December. The lawn on Chestnut is a placeholder. When trustees backed demolition, they approved turning the site into a lawn as a temporary use.

What the Oct. 13 meeting decided about the lawn, and what it left open

At a special Village Council study session on Tuesday, Oct. 13, trustees heard the results of a public engagement process run by Teska Associates and SB Friedman. According to The Record North Shore, 193 people came to the open houses and 679 answered the survey. Of the six concepts presented, participants picked out Concept 4. It's a "partial redevelopment" that keeps some open space, adds a 1- to 1.5-story commercial building that could be a restaurant, and adds parking.

Question Where it stood after Oct. 13
Leading concept Concept 4: some open space, a small commercial building, more parking
Runner-up with online participants Concept 3: more open space plus underground parking
Estimated cost to the village with underground parking $17.7 million
Estimated cost without underground parking $7.8 million
Next step An RFP/RFQ for open space and streetscape work, and an RFI asking developers about the north side of the site
Final decision Not imminent, per Village President Bob Dearborn

Dearborn was clear about how early this is. "This is one step along the way," he said, as quoted by The Record. A majority of trustees supported looking further at Concept 4. In the same Record account, Trustee Bridget Orsic said the plan keeps flexible space, and she added a point that matters to anyone who eats out downtown: "we do have a lot of restaurants that had wanted to come in but there was no space for them."

Not everyone agreed. Trustee Kim Handler argued against dropping underground parking despite the cost. Trustee Tina Dalman suggested asking the market for development options across the whole property. Trustee Scott Myers raised a boutique hotel, which several people also proposed during public comment.

Local business owners and residents spoke for both directions. According to The Record's meeting coverage, Kitty Brandtner, who owns Little Elm at 847 Elm St., told the council, "As a business owner, I would love to see more foot traffic bringing people in." Kip Robson favored Concept 4 and pictured the site as a summer gathering spot. As The Record reported, he said, "We bike to Kenilworth and Glencoe for the food trucks."

With no final decision imminent, the next step is for staff and consultants to issue a request for information and interview interested parties about what use fits any development on the site.

Across Elm, the building is up and the doors are shut

The lawn's future is open. One Winnetka's is mostly settled, just not yet ready. The mixed-use building at the southeast corner of Lincoln Avenue and Elm Street has topped out at four stories. The Village's Summer 2026 report scheduled public improvements from August through December and expected substantial completion in December. That report also said the retail spaces were fully leased and would be handed to tenants in October. That's the start of tenant build-out, which comes before any opening. Back in February, The Record put the first tenant openings in early 2027.

The ground-floor tenants are:

  • A Mediterranean restaurant from Ballyhoo Hospitality, the group behind Pomeroy in Winnetka, Sophia Steak in Wilmette and DeNucci's in Highland Park
  • Fare, a second restaurant
  • Solidcore, a fitness studio
  • Winnetka Aesthetic Studio, with Dr. Paul Phelps
  • DUET Preservation Audiology
  • Charles Schwab

If you've lost track of the restaurant's name, there's a reason. Ballyhoo first announced it as Arkadia. At the June 16 council meeting, the group's attorney said that name couldn't be used and a new one was being chosen. The building's own leasing site now lists "Cafe Kosta Restaurant by Ballyhoo Hospitality" among the retail coming soon. Earlier plans described about 6,700 square feet, 200 seats indoors, and a menu built around live-fire cooking, seafood and dips.

The corner changed in June as well. The council unanimously approved swapping the planned public plaza at Elm and Lincoln for a 17-table, 74-seat outdoor dining area surrounded by planters of native grasses. Planned hours are 4:30 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 4:30 to 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Winnetka's outdoor dining season runs April 1 to Nov. 30, and most of the planters go into storage outside those months. That season ends Nov. 30, ahead of the building's December completion target. If tenants open on the early-2027 schedule, spring 2027 is the earliest the patio could have diners.

As part of the change, Ballyhoo agreed to give $5,000 for up to five trees elsewhere in Winnetka, possibly at the former post office site. It also offered four magnolias on private property next to One Winnetka in place of the maples that won't go in.

On Chestnut, two small storefronts hold the block

The 500 block of Chestnut, between the lawn and Elm, is now quieter, and its smaller shops matter more. At 547 Chestnut, Allison Cassato opened The Lake Effect on June 12. It's an apparel and lifestyle boutique inspired by Lake Michigan, in the same address as her flower shop, as North Shore Weekly reported.

Next door at 549 Chestnut, The Classic Stitch is changing hands. After 20 years, owner Jane Hayes is passing the needlepoint shop to two protégées, Kathryn Cannon Weir and Mackenzie Reimer, who also run Third Coast Stitches at 1365 N. Wells St. in Chicago. In August, The Record reported their plan to reopen in October as Third Coast At The Classic Stitch. North Shore Weekly said no exact date had been set. Before you plan a stop for holiday canvases, call ahead to check the hours.

The calendar that fills in for the buildings

With the lawn on hold and the corner closed, the dates below give downtown its reasons to visit through early December. Every one is held in an existing venue or public space.

Date Event Where
Sat., Oct. 31, 7:30 a.m.–12:30 p.m. Chamber Farmers' Market 754 Elm St.
Fri., Nov. 6, 6:30–9:30 p.m. The Winnetka Edit opening party The Community House
Sat., Nov. 7, 10 a.m.–5 p.m. The Winnetka Edit show The Community House
Nov. 19–22 Annie the Musical The Community House
Fri., Dec. 4, treats 4:30–6:30 p.m., lights at 6 p.m. Holiday Tree Lighting Dwyer Park, near Elm and Birch
Sat., Dec. 5, 9–11:30 a.m. Winter Wanderland The Community House
Dec. 5 and 6, 1 and 4 p.m. both days A Christmas Carol The Community House

Tickets and details for the Community House events are on its ticket page. The Junior Board's Winter Wanderland includes Santa, holiday-themed scenes, treats and cocoa. One date to watch: the Chamber's page puts Friday, Dec. 4 in its headline, but the event description says "Friday, December 5th." Dec. 4 is the Friday in 2026, so the headline date matches the calendar.

Dec. 4 is when you'll see all of it in one evening

The tree lighting is the one night this season that brings the whole stretch together. According to the Chamber, the evening includes caroling, complimentary hot drinks and treats from 4:30 to 6:30 p.m., the lights coming on at 6 p.m., and Santa, his elves and a couple of reindeer after the lighting. The Chamber places Dwyer Park just behind the former post office, so the crowd will stand next to the lawn the village is still deciding on. Walk a block and you'll pass the ground floor at Elm and Lincoln, where the Village's summer schedule had tenants taking over their spaces in October and the first openings are expected in early 2027.

At Summerville Partners, we follow downtown Winnetka's changes block by block, from the post office lawn to the new building at Elm and Lincoln. If you own on these streets and want to know how the next few years of downtown could affect your home's value, request a free home valuation and we'll go through it with you.

Work With Us

Whether you are buying or selling a home, you’ve come to the right place to achieve success in Chicago’s exciting housing market.

Follow Us On Instagram